Siege 3.0.4 Becomes Part of the Problem

Siege 3.0.4 was just released. It contains a feature that I’ve added with a certain amount of reluctance. To understand the feature and the reason for my trepidation, let’s visit RFC 2616 and read what it has to say about Location headers:

For 3xx responses, the location SHOULD indicate theĀ server's
preferred URI for automatic redirection to the resource. TheĀ 
field value consists of a single absolute URI.
    Location = "Location" ":" absoluteURI
An example is:

That’s pretty clear, right? The value of a location header must be an absolute URI. Yet a large number of developers ignore that directive. Here’s the response from a server running SquirrelMail, a popular web-based email program:

     HTTP/1.1 302 Found
     Date: Tue, 17 Sep 2013 16:50:52 GMT
     Server: CERN/1.0A
     X-Powered-By: PHP/5.2.5
     Location: src/login.php
     Content-Length: 0
     Connection: close
     Content-Type: text/html; charset=WINDOWS-1251

Although that Location header violates RFC 2616, nearly every web client will follow it to SquirrelMail’s intended destination. I say “nearly every client.” Until version 3.0.4, siege wouldn’t have followed it any where. It would have scratched its head and said, “Fsck it. Next URL.”

It is with some reluctance that I’ve included siege in the community of clients that allow developers to circumvent established standards. This convention has created a slew of bad coding practices on the world wide web. Didn’t close a table with an end tag? That’s okay, M$ will close it for you. Used a relative URI in a Location header? Don’t worry, siege will normalize it for you.

Ironically, version 3.0.4 includes one other feature enhancement. Its default User-agent is now in full compliance with RFC 2616. You win some, you lose some. And so it goes….

Posted in Applications, Siege | 5 Comments

Recent Comments

  • Tim: For those who enjoy playing at home and are extra OCD … they’ll spot something wrong with this....
  • roshni: Hi jeff, I need your help regarding running urls in a file containing post directives. Could you please send...
  • Alle: In seige, what does the pink result mean?
  • Windows User: Nice collection of Perl modules. Thanks for sharing.
  • Jeff Fulmer: No idea. What do you see in the webserver’s logs?